It happened again last week - a limp test match performance against Sri Lanka with face saved only by yet another piece of Daniel Vettori batting prowess; followed by a much more convincing showing at limited overs cricket. It leads us to the question, and not for the first time: Why is New Zealand so poor in test cricket? Or, put another way: Why can’t the other Black Caps bat as well as Vettori? Paul Lewis investigates.

It’s embarrassing. As we pointed out in these pages last week, over the past three years, skipper Daniel Vettori is the top or second-top scorer in around one out of every three tests - and that from a No 8 batsman who, by any measure, is not the most attractive nor most talented bat around. We typically see Vettori leading a fightback, face pinched with concentration, defending well and waiting for the ball to come from which he can score. He has a good eye, a small array of shots from which he can profit and is a vastly experienced cricketer with a deep well of guts and stubbornness. He averages in the 30s and 40s for his last 2000 runs in test cricket.

These are qualities this country has previously come to expect from its test cricketers. Fans were raised with few genuinely world-class players like Richard Hadlee, Glenn Turner or Martin Crowe to enjoy. Instead, many well-performed New Zealand batsmen came to the international game with solid defensive techniques and a determination not to sell their wicket cheaply; to occupy the crease, bat time, outlast and out-manoeuvre.

We’re talking your Bevan Congdons, the skipper when New Zealand won its first test against Australia in the 1970s and who made a pair of centuries in successive tests against England, Read more…

Administrator New Zealand Australia, Black Caps, Blogs.CMDN.com, Brendon McCullum, Bruce Edgar, Cricket, Cricket Blogs, Daniel Vettori, England, Glenn Turner, Jacob Oram, Jeremy Coney, John F Reid, John Wright, Kumar Sangakkara, Mahela Jayawardene, Mark Richardson, Martin Crowe, Martin Guptill, New Zealand, Oram, Paul Lewis, Richard Hadlee, Sri Lanka